This is a rant-type thing. Please don't be offended by anything said in here, if I was speaking about anyone's personal fanfiction, I would have left a review on the story offering the constructive criticism that was needed.
____________________________________
Why does it seem to all suck, lately?
A lofty claim, I know, but it feels like it has been so long since I've read a great fanfiction. A truly compelling story about the characters that you love. One that you are begging for an update, that you check
every single day. Or, one that you find late at night. You know that you have to go to bed, you have to be up in three hours, but you
can't stop scrolling.
What happened? I feel like every thing I click on lately is crap, crap, CRAP. Is it that I've changed?
I mean, I'm not 13 anymore. I've grown, my tastes have changed, and I have read so much since then: am I simply noticing the things that I easily looked over in the past? Does it just take more to dazzle me now?
Is it the accessibility and instant gratification of the fanfiction sites? With sites like ff.net, anyone can rattle off 5 words and declare it an opus. They post it with zero editing, zero thought and insight into the role that fanfiction should have with canon, and zero accountability.
It seems that everyone wants to be an author, and that's fine. I love to read, I think that the world would be better with more writers. Afterall, aren't we the sensitive, thoughtful types? Quick to ponder, quicker to appreciate the work of another.
But with ff.net, everyone becomes a writer with that "upload" button, and it seems that more and more defensive writers are citing "Plz don't flame me, this is my first fic" or seems to hide behind the "it's just fanfic, I'm not a professional" tirade.
Which is all frankly bullshit as far as I'm concerned. I have read some great fanfiction in the last 10 years, some written by men and women who deserve (and may well be) professional authors. Regardless of your writing experience when you hit that button every fanfic writer becomes a published author.
Published.
Doesn't that in itself create accountability?
Is it the vanity reviewing? How can crap authors really expect to grow when no one gives any real criticism? I read 13 fanfictions today, each one worst than the last. The worst being a Buffy the Vampire Slayer story: a time travel story of such absurd proportions I could only make it through 4 chapters before closing it in disgust.
I clicked on the reviews
(81 reviews 81 reviews?!), and not one had any criticism. Constructive or otherwise, just "update plz" or "so hottttt"
Nothing about the disgusting misuse of characters, discarded plot, inability to properly punctuate, and the occasional slip of chat speak.
I've received constructive criticism and see? I'm still here. I didn't spontaneously combust. My soul didn't die inside my broken, frail body. I made the changes that I needed to, and my story became better.
One particular harsh CC really opened my eyes, and I remember the advice that I received. It truly changed my writing. Is that what today's authors need?
What happened to beta readers?
I used to be on a beta reader index for theforce.net, and my inbox would be flooded with beta requests, so much so that I had to remove my name from the listing. I selected to exclusively beta six authors. These people refused to update something until it was beta read, going as far as to resubmit something to me three times to ensure that it was perfectly tweaked. I wasn't the only one with this beta/author relationship. The entire board it was taboo if you didn't have a beta. If you didn't have one, people scrambled to find you one.
What happened to the characters? What happened to the story?
I like smut. I like lemons. I like limes. I'm a sweaty, Sprite kind of girl.
But when your entire premise of a story is about saving someone from the present that you love, have them proactively try to protect them. The aforementioned BtVS fic had the first four chapters a supposedly 21 year old Buffy is incapable of doing anything but wax poetic (bad poetic) on how "hott (sic)" Angel's human self was. Upon their first meeting she screws him in an alley.
Which sex in alleys is fine. I like PWPs. Remember the Sprite?
But it's when PWP completely loses sight of the characters. If you want to write about two people having sex, write original characters and post it as original erotica. Don't destroy two beloved characters for the sake of getting off.
What happened to stories? What happened to the canon tie-in? Alternate Universes are fine, when done right. And most AU fics that seem to work have some tie into canon, somewhere.
I won't start on Mary Sues. Frankly because I'm sick of talking about her, reading about her, and thinking about her. Enough people have ranted on her for five lifetimes.
But my biggest heartache stems from: What happened to plot and character driven drama?
________________________________________
__
Anyway, that's my rant. I'm off to find not crappy fic. Any suggestions of where to look?
Also, to reiterate, I'm talking about none of my friends here. I leave constructive criticism where I read, and would have left it with you if I thought you needed it.